By Adam Kelliher
The short answer: agate is a banded, translucent form of chalcedony, which is quartz made of crystals too small to see. In the field, look for three things together: light glowing through thin edges, curved or concentric bands, and a waxy look on broken surfaces. It's hard, at 6.5 to 7 on the Mohs scale.[1][2]
Agate is one of the first things most rockhounds learn to spot, and also one of the most mislabelled. Here's a checklist that works on a beach, a gravel bar or a shop table.
1. Hold it up to the light
Agate is translucent. Shine a torch or the sun behind a thin edge and light comes through, even when the middle is dark. Put your hand between the light and the stone and the glow disappears.[2] Opaque material that lets no light through at all is more likely jasper. We cover agate versus jasper in a separate post.
2. Look for bands
Most agate formed when silica-rich water filled a cavity, often in volcanic rock, and laid down layer after layer. The layers follow the walls of the cavity, giving onion-like concentric bands. Some agates also have flat, horizontal bands that settled at the bottom of the cavity.[1][3] The bands are mostly changes in translucency, with colour sometimes added by other minerals.[1]
Not every agate is banded. Moss, plume and dendritic agates are translucent chalcedony with mineral inclusions instead of stripes.[2]

3. Check the lustre on a break
Agate's lustre is waxy to dull, turning glassy only when polished.[1] That's a useful way to tell it from crystalline quartz. A fresh break on quartz is bright and glassy. On chalcedony the break cuts across millions of tiny crystals, which scatter the light and give that softer, waxy look.[2]
4. Look at the fracture
Agate has no cleavage. It breaks with smooth, curved, shell-like conchoidal fractures.[1]
5. Test the hardness
Agate is 6.5 to 7 on the Mohs scale, as hard or nearly as hard as quartz.[1] Test on a hidden spot. Our home ID post covers how to do a scratch test properly.
6. Wet it
Rough agate often looks dull and chalky. Water coats the surface and imitates a polish, so you can see the real colour and pattern underneath. It's why rock dealers keep spray bottles and tubs of water nearby.[4]

A note on colour
Agate is slightly porous and takes dye easily.[1] GIA notes that very intense pink, blue or green agates are often dyed.[5] Natural agate covers a big range, but if the colour looks electric, ask.
Where to start
In BC, the Okanagan is well known for agate. See Why Are There So Many Agates in the Okanagan?. To compare pieces in hand, browse translucent lapidary rough and all rough rock.
Agate sits at about 7 on the Mohs scale, so a scratch test helps you identify agate in the field. A Mohs hardness scale education set makes the comparison easy, and our Mohs hardness guide explains the scale.
See what's new: browse our newest arrivals for the latest pieces added to the shop.
Sources
- Mindat.org (Hudson Institute of Mineralogy): Agate.
- RockTumbler.com (Hobart M. King): The Difference Between Agate, Jasper and Chalcedony.
- Geology.com: Agate.
- Adam Kelliher, Beyond Cabbing: Volume I, Cutting a Cabochon (the water dunk).
- GIA: Gem Cutters Reveal the Beauty of Chalcedony.

