15 piece mineral set

By Adam Kelliher

The short answer: a mineral is a naturally occurring, inorganic solid with a set chemical makeup and an orderly internal structure. A rock is a mix of one or more minerals. A crystal is any solid whose atoms are arranged in a repeating pattern, including minerals, but also things like the sugar crystals you can grow in a kitchen.[1]

People use these three words interchangeably, and in a shop that's mostly fine. But knowing the difference makes labels, field guides and identification much easier.

Minerals: the building blocks

USGS defines a mineral as a naturally occurring inorganic element or compound with an orderly internal structure and a characteristic chemical composition, crystal form and physical properties.[1] Quartz is silicon dioxide. Calcite is calcium carbonate. Pyrite is iron sulphide. Each one has a recipe and a structure, which is why the tests in our home ID post work.

Calcite specimen from the Linwood Mine, Iowa
Calcite from Iowa. One mineral, one recipe. (photo: Rubble Rock & Gem)

Rocks: the mixtures

A rock is an aggregate of one or more minerals, or of mineral matter that isn't sorted into distinct minerals. Rocks don't have one set chemical formula or crystal structure.[1] Granite, for example, is a mix of quartz, feldspar and mica. Geologists group rocks by how they formed: igneous, sedimentary and metamorphic. The Rock Trilogy walks through all three.

Sedimentary rocks education set
A sedimentary rock set. Each rock is a mixture, not a single mineral. (photo: Rubble Rock & Gem)

Crystals: a structure, not a category

"Crystal" describes how atoms are arranged, not what something is made of. Minerals have an orderly internal structure even when you can't see any crystal faces.[1] When a mineral has room to grow, it can form the flat faces and points people picture as "crystals". That outward shape is called habit, covered in crystal habits.

Some edge cases

  • Obsidian is a natural volcanic glass with no orderly structure, so it's a rock (and a mineraloid), not a mineral.[3]
  • Amber and pearl come from living things, so they aren't minerals by the strict definition.[3]
  • Natural ice counts as a mineral: natural, inorganic, solid and crystalline. An ice cube from your freezer doesn't, because it isn't naturally formed.[2]
Pyrite cubes gem dirt
Pyrite cubes. The cube shape reflects the mineral's internal structure. (photo: Rubble Rock & Gem)

The easy way to learn it

Hold the real thing. Our rock and mineral sets put labelled samples side by side, and you'll find single-mineral pieces in mineral specimens.

Hardness is one simple way to tell a rock from a mineral or crystal. Try it with a Mohs hardness scale education set, and read our guide to the Mohs scale.

See what's new: browse our newest arrivals for the latest pieces added to the shop.

Sources

  1. USGS (US Geological Survey): What Is the Difference Between a Rock and a Mineral?
  2. Geology.com (Hobart M. King): Is Water a Mineral? Is Ice a Mineral?
  3. Geology.com: What Is a Mineraloid?; Organic Gemstones.

Related Reads